Cookieless List

Google Analytics without a cookie banner: your options

In the US, no state law requires an opt-in banner before Google Analytics 4 runs, but its data goes to Google, which raises opt-out and CIPA questions. In the EU, GA4’s cookies need consent; consent mode only changes what Google collects after a refusal. Running without a banner there usually means a different tool.

Updated

What GA4 sets and sends

  • Cookies: _ga (2 years, distinguishes users) and _ga_<container-id> (2 years, keeps session state). Linking a Google Ads account adds advertising cookies.
  • Data sharing: with the “Google products & services” setting on, Google can analyze your data and use it to improve Google products and services, such as Google Ads tools.
  • IP addresses: Google says GA4 does not log or store IP addresses of users in the EU, Switzerland or the UK; it derives coarse location (city, region, country) from them.
  • Consent mode: when consent is denied, tags do not store cookies and send “cookieless pings” with a minimum of information instead.

Where GA4 needs a banner

GA4 and consent, by region
RegionBanner before GA4?Why
United StatesNot required by state lawOpt-out model: disclose it in the privacy policy; if data is shared for cross-context advertising, offer “Do Not Sell or Share” and honor Global Privacy Control
European UnionYesGA4 stores identifiers on the device, and its sharing settings let Google use the data for its own products, which audience-measurement exemptions such as the CNIL’s rule out
United KingdomOnly if the exception fitsThe 2026 exception covers storage used only for statistics about your own service; check GA4’s sharing and advertising settings against that test with counsel

In the US the open question is CIPA, not consent law. GA4 sends visit data to Google, a separate company: the third-party pattern behind pen-register suits (Shah v. Fandom). Google was among the trackers named in the Kaiser case. SB 690 removes private pen-register suits from 2027; section 631 wiretap claims remain.

Your options

Ways to run analytics, with or without a banner
OptionBannerTrade-off
Keep GA4 behind a consent banner, with consent modeYesWorks in every region and is a consent defense to CIPA claims; you lose detail on visitors who refuse
Keep GA4 without a banner (US-only audience)NoDisclose it, consider switching off Google products & services sharing and Ads links, honor opt-outs; third-party data flow to Google remains
Switch to a cookieless analytics vendorDepends on region and configurationCheck what it stores on the device, whether it uses your data for itself, and whether it records replay or typed text
Self-host open-source analyticsDepends on configurationData never leaves you, the strongest position under the party exception; you run the servers
Server-log analytics, no client scriptLeast likely to need oneLeast to consent to, but least detail; the EDPB’s IP-tracking reading can still apply

Questions

Can I use Google Analytics without a cookie banner?
In the US, state law does not require one, though you must disclose GA4 and honor opt-outs if data is shared for advertising. In the EU, GA4 needs consent for its cookies. Consent mode does not remove the banner; it changes what Google collects when visitors refuse.
Does consent mode make GA4 cookieless?
Only for visitors who deny consent. Then tags store no cookies and send cookieless pings to Google instead. Visitors who accept get the normal _ga cookies.

Sources

  1. Google Analytics Help: cookie usage on websites
  2. Google Analytics Help: data sharing settings
  3. Google Analytics Help: EU, Switzerland or UK-focused data and privacy
  4. Google Analytics Help: consent mode on websites and mobile apps
  5. CookieYes: US cookie consent requirements
  6. California Privacy Protection Agency: CCPA statute (effective January 1, 2026)
  7. EDPB Guidelines 2/2023 on the technical scope of Art. 5(3) ePrivacy Directive (v2)
  8. CNIL: solutions pour les outils de mesure d’audience
  9. ICO: what are the exceptions (storage and access technologies)
  10. Shah v. Fandom, Inc. (vLex)
  11. DataTrue: Kaiser Permanente pixel settlement
  12. Mayer Brown: California invalidates private lawsuits for pen-register website claims

This note is general information compiled from public sources, not legal advice. Laws and cases change; ask your own counsel before you rely on it.